Jump to content

The "If you had my fighters" thread


Timmy

Recommended Posts

It's my turn. I reviewed Bjorn's fighters and no one has reviewed mine yet.

BEST FIGHTER

Russian Obama. Very well rounded fighter. Should probably be moved up to a big name org soon, as he needs a step up in competition.

BEST PROSPECT

Yomomza Thundercunt. He's done well in MMA, but if I were you I would keep training his striking and wrestling and get him into KT, his build is perfect for it. Especially because KT is on the quick rise with Dynasty at the head of it. This guy is a keeper. (Just saw Mick Murphy, all this applies to him as well, but he's got a better chance of going far in MMA than thundercunt does IMO.)

WORST FIGHTER

Luis Torres. His chin is weak. He's taken many straight KOs in his long career which is concerning. I would say cut him, but you did the right thing getting him to a lesser org to give him a step down in competition, his advantage in skill should overcome his weak chin there. But, if he doesn't do very well I would cut him personally.

GENERAL REMARKS

Your roster seems very average. Nobody was disgustingly bad but nobody was noteably impressive either. You seem to have many guys who have a lot of skill but also have weak chins. You're winning fights with these guys but not at the highest level, and as a manger you seem to be ready for the highest level. I would cut the weak chinned guys and keep the prospects (Thundercunt, Murphy and Ragnarsson all have bright futures.)

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Snape was a cool free agent pick; he's up there, but he still has a few fights left in him and he could be a lot of fun.

 

I didn't include any free agent in my review; I wanted to keep it to the fighters you created yourself.

 

Best Prospect: Sokolov snapped off a QFC win against another test fighter, so that doesn't give me much to work with. Ambrose popped big heart, which isn't necessarily horrible but isn't great, either. Diamond Jackson got granite chin, so once his skills are up to par he should be decent enough. Overall, I think Sokolov might end up being your best fighter, on a hunch.

 

Worst Fighter: I predict that Rollins will get knocked out in the future (a lot), but Seamus Hunter is hopelessly under skilled and is popping Experienced after that many fights. I would have cut him a long time ago.

 

Best Fighter: right now, it's Chet Rollins, but only while he preys on weak competition. He is a good litmus test for the scrubs, but not much more than that unfortunately. But until your prospects get trained up and with your free agents excluded, I'd say Chet Rollins is your best fighter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Snape was a cool free agent pick; he's up there, but he still has a few fights left in him and he could be a lot of fun.

 

I didn't include any free agent in my review; I wanted to keep it to the fighters you created yourself.

 

Best Prospect: Sokolov snapped off a QFC win against another test fighter, so that doesn't give me much to work with. Ambrose popped big heart, which isn't necessarily horrible but isn't great, either. Diamond Jackson got granite chin, so once his skills are up to par he should be decent enough. Overall, I think Sokolov might end up being your best fighter, on a hunch.

 

Worst Fighter: I predict that Rollins will get knocked out in the future (a lot), but Seamus Hunter is hopelessly under skilled and is popping Experienced after that many fights. I would have cut him a long time ago.

 

Best Fighter: right now, it's Chet Rollins, but only while he preys on weak competition. He is a good litmus test for the scrubs, but not much more than that unfortunately. But until your prospects get trained up and with your free agents excluded, I'd say Chet Rollins is your best fighter.

I agree that Hunter is an awkward build with a weak chin, he'll likely be on the chopping block relatively soon. As for Rollins I'm going to ride his success out as long as possible, but I do see guys like Sokolov passing him soon. Thanks for the review!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...

For TonyScat:

 

Best Fighter:

 

Sounds like an obvious one; but I would probably go with Rickson Moura; just because he has wins by both knockout and submission, which can be pretty rare on this game. He also seems to have a pretty good chin, only been KO'd once although I wouldn't necessarily bet on that because you don't know for sure. Has potential; but maybe still needs a bit of time off of fighting to train so that he can max out all his skills.

 

Best Prospect:

Tough choice here; I would say it comes down to one of Ghostface Killa and James Franklin. Killa is a Heavyweight with power, but at that weight-class, the jury is out until his chin and heart gets tested. Franklin popped for determined, so I'd just about give him the nod here as he also has good power for the weight-class, and the heart will help him once he develops to a higher level. Both good prospects and it will be interesting to see how they develop.

 

Worst Fighter/Sack:

Probably out of the prospects I would say Wallid Cozad; yes he is undefeated in the QFC and has a potent ground game. However popping Self Confident is a BAD thing, and he is likely to get found out at some point.

I am also not the biggest fan of Ken Tanaka; I'm sure you had your reasons for picking him up and he does have good power, however his chin just doesn't look good enough to ever be top level at HW or SW.

 

Overall Opinion:

Odin Thorsen is a fighter I remember well; when he beat the holy hell out of my bum fighter Bret The Grinder. On the whole, as a manager I feel you are at a very competent level, and you seem to be able to create guys that can finish by knockout or submission, which is a real breath of fresh air in a game of striking specialists. The only bit of advice I would offer comes from a training perspective; everyone has their own way of doing things, but some of your guys are popping physicals in their first fight, which means that you'll never see their best hidden. This can be problematic as you may not know until they reach the top level what kind of heart and chin they have. Overall though, very young decent looking roster :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would like an opinion on Jack "the hunk" dawson

 

I know he has had only 1 fight but I would love opinions

 

People have downvoted you Raichu because you are not keeping to the format.

Read the first post of the thread to see how it works.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Slice

 

Best Fighter: Keyser Sose: I would say The Hound is your best fighter, and the fact that The Hound has only been TKOd once is pretty impressive, but with Keyser being only 23 and already having an impressive record, I'm gonna have to go with Keyser. He still has a lot of time left on his hands for growing and knocking fools out.

 

Best Prospect: Vinnie Victory: The 19 year old granite chin and seems to learn pretty quickly. Im already a fan. :thumbup:

 

Worst Fighter: Julian Richardson: It was pretty tough picking your worst fighter because they all arent really that bad in my opinion, but Julian stuck out as the worst fighter for me because of his record and his hiddens arent as good as the rest of your fighters.

 

Overall: Your future is looking bright and I can't wait to see how each of your fighters do at their full potential :training2:

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 11 months later...

I would like to hear what other people think of my developing fighters, and what I'm doing wrong or right. Clint, Road and Duke are all in creation tournaments so can't be cut.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...