Has anyone ever had problems with the decision system of this game?!

[TheButcher1877]

Here is the commentary for my fight. My fighter was 'Coverdale'... Is it just me or does the ENTIRE commentary not say that Coverdale stuffed literally every takedown and also countered like a mad man, while Smith could do nothing... YET, Smith still won all rounds?!?!?!?1 wtf? I'll paste the commentary below:

 

 

Ladies and gentlemen. This fight is 3 rounds, in the bantamweight division.

Introducing the fighter to my left, fighting out of the red corner.

With a record of 0 wins, 0 losses and 0 draws, fighting out of Montreal, Teddy Coverdale!

And introducing the fighter to my right, fighting out of the blue corner.

With a record of 0 wins, 0 losses and 0 draws, fighting out of Montreal, Lector Smith!

The judges for this bout are Elvis Blanc, Robert Douchet and Dillan Fox.

 

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/round1.jpg

The bell rings for round one and we are underway!

Smith fails in his attempt to clinch.

Smith closes the distance looking to clinch

and Coverdale counters with a nice body kick.

A chopping leg kick lands by Smith.

The fight stays on the outside here - Smith looks like he's thinking about clinching though.

Smith is looking to take this fight into the clinch.

Smith closes this distance looking for a takedown but Coverdale circles away.

Coverdale sees a low kick coming and goes to check it, but it's actually a body kick and it thuds into his unprotected ribs.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/1.gif

That's one minute gone in the round.

Smith looks for the body kick but Coverdale saw that one coming.

Smith misses with a body shot. Nice footwork from Coverdale.

Smith fails with the takedown.

Smith with a lazy takedown attempt

and Coverdale counters with a leg kick that reverborates around the arena.

Teddy Coverdale has stuffed three takedown attempts in the round now. That's going to take a lot out of Lector Smith.

Smith throws a leg kick but Coverdale sees it coming and checks it nicely.

Smith shoots in but doesn't get the takedown

and Coverdale connects with a straight left hand counter down the middle.

Smith tries to close the distance and clinch up against the cage but Coverdale paws at him with a jab and circles away.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/2.gif

That's two minutes gone in the round.

Smith fails with the takedown

and Coverdale counters with a leg kick.

Smith lunges in with swinging rights and lefts but Coverdale circles away quickly and effectively.

Smith throws a head kick but Coverdale moves out of range.

Smith looks winded!

Smith closes the distance looking to clinch

and Coverdale counters with a nice body kick.

Smith shoots in but doesn't get the takedown

and he gets countered with a snapping leg kick.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/3.gif

That's three minutes gone in the round.

Smith gets his takedown attempt stuffed easily

and Coverdale counters with a series of strikes. Smith will be more careful next time no doubt.

A head kick by Smith misses

and Coverdale counters with a series of strikes. Smith will be more careful next time no doubt.

Smith tries to clinch there but Coverdale circles away.

Smith tries to clinch but Coverdale moves out of range.

Smith doesn't succeed with the takedown

and Coverdale counters with a left and a right that stings Smith.

Smith shoots and misses

and Coverdale counters with a one-two to the body.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/4.gif

That's four minutes gone in the round.

Smith shoots and misses

and Coverdale counters with an outside leg kick.

Smith has his takedown stuffed

and Coverdale counters with a head kick.

Coverdale avoids the head kick by Smith.

Smith tries a switch kick but it misses it's target.

Smith gets his takedown attempt stuffed easily

and Coverdale counters with a three punch combination, finished off with a leg kick. Nice work.

Smith shoots and misses

and Coverdale counters nicely by changing levels and landing a hook to the body.

Lector Smith seems to be the more aggressive standup fighter in this bout.

Coverdale avoids the clinch attempt nicely.

And that’s the end of the round – the fighters go back to their corners.

 

Lector Smith dominated that round.

The corners get their ten second warning. Both fighters stand from their stools and stare eachother down, ready to get back to the action.

 

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/round2.jpg

Smith throws a lazy head kick

and Coverdale makes him pay by landing a nice hook to the body before moving out of range.

Coverdale leaves Smith with his face pressed against the mat as he sprawls beautifully, defending against a solid takedown attempt.

Coverdale blocks a head kick by Smith.

Smith misses with a hook

and Coverdale counters with a series of strikes. Smith will be more careful next time no doubt.

Smith shoots in for a takedown. He's persisting with it as Coverdale sprawls well. Coverdale wins this battle and keeps the fight standing. Smith gets slowly back to his feet.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/clinch2.gif

The fight moves into the clinch position.

Smith is breathing heavily.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/1.gif

That's one minute gone in the round.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/breakclinch.gif

Coverdale escapes the clinch and we're back to striking.

Smith tries to clinch but Coverdale is having none of it.

Smith throws a big shot that misses.

Smith shoots in and drives through. Coverdale sprawls well.

Teddy Coverdale has stuffed three takedown attempts in the round now. That's going to take a lot out of Lector Smith.

Smith shoots in and drives through. Coverdale sprawls well.

Smith tries to clinch up against the cage, rushing in to close the distance. Coverdale manages to break the clinch and circles back to the middle of the mat.

Smith is looking to take this fight into the clinch.

Smith throws a leg kick that is checked

and Coverdale counters with a three punch combination, finished off with a leg kick. Nice work.

http://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/2.gif

That's two minutes gone in the round.

Smith dives in and grabs Coverdale's left leg, looking for a takedown. Coverdale pushes down on Smith's head and hops out.

Smith throws a leg kick that is checked

and Coverdale counters with a three punch combo that has Smith backing up. Smith nods at Coverdale to acknowledge the strikes.

Smith swings wildly with a couple of big hooks

and Coverdale counters with a solid body kick.

Smith with a lazy takedown attempt

and Coverdale counters with a thumping low kick.

Smith misses with a takedown attempt

and Coverdale counters with a two punch combo.

Smith misses with a half-hearted attempt at a head kick.

Smith fails with the takedown.

Smith shoots and misses

and Coverdale counters with a one-two to the body.

Smith fails to land the takedown.

http://www.mmatycoon...ges/fight/3.gif

That's three minutes gone in the round.

Smith shoots and misses

and Coverdale counters with a solid body kick.

Smith throws a left and a right that both miss

and Coverdale counters with a two punch combo.

Coverdale is working the combinations to good effect here.

Coverdale avoids the head kick by Smith.

Smith tries to grapple but his opponent circles

and Coverdale counters with a three punch combination, finished off with a leg kick. Nice work.

Smith misses with a takedown attempt

and Coverdale counters with a one-two to the body.

Smith has his takedown stuffed

and Coverdale counters with a slapping leg kick.

http://www.mmatycoon...ges/fight/4.gif

That's four minutes gone in the round.

Smith throws a low kick but Coverdale moves out of range easily.

Smith ducks down and throws a hook to the body but Coverdale moves away.

No luck for Smith with that takedown attempt.

Smith tries to clinch but Coverdale moves away

and Coverdale makes him pay by landing a thudding low kick.

Smith fails with the takedown

and Coverdale counters with a three punch combo that has Smith backing up. Smith nods at Coverdale to acknowledge the strikes.

The crowd applaud the fighters efforts here as the round comes to an end.

Smith shoots in for a takedown but Coverdale shows good takedown defense there and keeps this one on the feet.

And that’s the end of the round – the fighters go back to their corners.

 

A close second round but Lector Smith will probably get the nod - 10:9.

That's time! Coverdale's corner gives him a slap on the ass as he gets ready to fight. The crowd applaud as we get ready to start the final round!

 

http://www.mmatycoon...ight/round3.jpg

Smith misses with a takedown attempt. He shot from a bit too far out.

The fight stays on the outside here - Smith looks like he's thinking about clinching though.

Smith tries to score with an inside leg kick but telegraphs it and Coverdale is able to avoid easily.

Lector Smith seems to be getting the better of the standup.

A punch combination from Smith misses.

We've had a slow start to the round here - hopefully the action picks up.

Smith shoots in for a takedown. "I don't think so" says Coverdale as he avoids it easily.

Smith takes a big intake of breath there - he's definitely tired.

Smith fails with an attempt to clinch.

Smith shoots in for a takedown but doesn't get it.

Teddy Coverdale has stuffed three takedown attempts in the round now. That's going to take a lot out of Lector Smith.

http://www.mmatycoon...ges/fight/1.gif

That's one minute gone in the round.

Smith shoots and misses

and Coverdale counters with a leg kick that reverborates around the arena.

Coverdale avoids the head kick by Smith.

Smith with a poor takedown

and Coverdale counters with a left and a right that stings Smith.

Smith misses with a low kick.

Smith closes the distance but Coverdale moves to the side

and Coverdale counters with a one-two to the body.

Smith gets his takedown attempt stuffed easily

and Coverdale counters with an outside leg kick.

http://www.mmatycoon...ges/fight/2.gif

That's two minutes gone in the round.

Smith fails with a takedown attempt from distance.

Smith throws a sloppy head kick and Coverdale moves out of range easily.

Smith misses with a few strikes there.

Smith shoots in but doesn't get the takedown

and Coverdale counters with a three punch combo that has Smith backing up. Smith nods at Coverdale to acknowledge the strikes.

Smith doesn't succeed with the takedown

and Coverdale counters with a series of strikes. Smith will be more careful next time no doubt.

Smith misses with a few strikes there.

Smith looks to land a body kick but Coverdale moved away.

http://www.mmatycoon...ges/fight/3.gif

That's three minutes gone in the round.

Coverdale moves out of range of the leg kick from Smith.

Coverdale stuffs the takedown.

Smith has his takedown stuffed

and he gets countered with a snapping leg kick.

Coverdale avoids the clinch attempt nicely.

Smith tries for a takedown but Coverdale circles away easily

and Coverdale counters with a big head kick but Smith shrugs it off.

Smith throws a combination but comes up with nothing but fresh air.

Smith's leg has a nasty welt from taking a succession of leg kicks. That must be slowing him down.

http://www.mmatycoon...ges/fight/4.gif

That's four minutes gone in the round.

Coverdale showing good head movement there, avoiding the strikes from Smith.

Smith shoots in for a takedown. He's persisting with it as Coverdale sprawls well. Coverdale wins this battle and keeps the fight standing. Smith gets slowly back to his feet.

Smith misses with a hook

and Coverdale counters with a one-two to the body.

Smith throws the kick towards the body but Coverdale avoids it.

Smith is looking to clinch but Coverdale is avoiding it.

Smith tries to clinch up

and Coverdale counters with a good low kick that Smith was not able to check.

 

And that's the end of the fight!

Lector Smith comfortably won the final round on my scorecard.

Well Smith has outworked and out performed his opponent in all aspects of the game today. He was simply too good and the decision should be no more than a formality. Over to the ring announcer for the scorecards.

 

Ladies and gentlemen, after 3 rounds of action, we go to the scorecards for a decision.

Judge Elvis Blanc scores the fight 27:30

Judge Robert Douchet scores the fight 27:30

Judge Dillan Fox scores the fight 27:30

 

In favor of your winner, by unanimous decision... Lector Smith!

[PBR]

really tough decision -- im guess you went 100 accuracy which is the only thing i could think of that might of caused it -- instead of punching with damage you were like slapping him -- but yes system does have bad decisions just like real life

[duphus]

http://www.mmatycoon.com/fightcommentary.php?FTID=597009

 

 

Ya, that one is a little weird?

 

what was you on damage/Acc?

[duphus]

Since your not VIP you can't see these stats but here they are:

Coverdale Standuphttp://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/imperialspacer.gif

Head punch: 1 (1)

Body punch: 2 (2)

Punch combo: 19 (19)

Head kick: 2 (2)

Leg kick: 11 (11)

Body kick: 4 (4)

Takedown: 0 (0)

Clinchwork

Head punch: 0 (0)

Body punch: 0 (0)

Elbow: 0 (0)

Knee head: 0 (0)

Knee body: 0 (0)

Takedowns: 0 (0)

Groundwork

Improve pos: 0 (0)

Ground strikes: 0 (0)

Sub attempts: 0 (0)

 

 

Smith:

 

Standuphttp://www.mmatycoon.com/images/fight/imperialspacer.gif

Head punch: 3 (0)

Body punch: 2 (0)

Punch combo: 8 (0)

Head kick: 10 (0)

Leg kick: 8 (1)

Body kick: 4 (1)

Takedown: 42 (0)

Clinchwork

Head punch: 0 (0)

Body punch: 0 (0)

Elbow: 0 (0)

Knee head: 0 (0)

Knee body: 0 (0)

Takedowns: 0 (0)

Groundwork

Improve pos: 0 (0)

Ground strikes: 0 (0)

Sub attempts: 0 (0)

[DeadDisney]

really tough decision -- im guess you went 100 accuracy which is the only thing i could think of that might of caused it -- instead of punching with damage you were like slapping him -- but yes system does have bad decisions just like real life

 

It doesn't necessarily have to be him going 100 acc to lose a decision like this, right? What if he went say 70 acc and just had a really low natural ko hidden? Add a lack of aggression (via mostly countering) and I could see how he could lose a decision here. Not saying that he should have lost, just sayin'.

 

OP:

 

Edit: Btw, each judge has his own style of judging and there is a chance you could have been robbed. I point people here if a fight just completely defies logic, but only as a last resort: http://www.mmatycoon...hp?title=Judges

 

Edit 2: Just looked over your fight again and I noticed that according to all three judges your guy lost every round. The few robberies that I've seen had more disparity in the scoring.

[TheButcher1877]

That is true. Real life has bad decisions so maybe this is the best way to make the game realistic! However, yes, I am not VIP so I do not understand those stats. But could someone explain to me or make a suggestion maybe then... Is it bad to have a counter fighter?!?! Cause to me, I feel I shouldve won but it seems I lost due to a lack of aggression?

[duphus]

what was you on the damage / accurate slider?

[TheButcher1877]

90% accurate, 10% damage

[DeadDisney]

90% accurate, 10% damage

 

Well, there you have it -- too little damage. You'll have to figure out how much accuracy you can get away with, and it varies per fighter. However, I'd consider 90% acc to be too little damage in any case.

[CharlesLeeRay]

I just looked at the points breakdown and I can't see the difference. -.-

[Guest]

Irrelevant of whether he points fought or not, it is still a robbery and a poor decision.

 

Landing 39 girly love taps still beats his opponent's 2 low kicks that didn't knockdown, cut or rock him. The ability to stuff 49 takedown attempts should also be worth something in itself given the scoring strength of a single successful takedown.

[Guest]

It's one of the worst decision that I ever had seen. One leg and body kick in the whole fight gives 10:9 point in each round? 42 TD attempts? I would say that Teddy was robbed, but I know that game's scoring system favours dmg than accuracy. Brutal strenght over precision. But as KRad wrote, your fighter outlanded him with the striking and defended his TD attempts.

 

Better luck next time,

Bragi~

[DeadDisney]

Irrelevant of whether he points fought or not, it is still a robbery and a poor decision.

 

Landing 39 girly love taps still beats his opponent's 2 low kicks that didn't knockdown, cut or rock him. The ability to stuff 49 takedown attempts should also be worth something in itself given the scoring strength of a single successful takedown.

 

I see your point here, but I'm guessing it's an engine flaw and not a "poor decision/robbery". None of the judges gave the "loser" a single round, and the commentator saw the fight the same as the judges.

 

Fruitless aggression vs sissy slapping/non-aggression was the order and fruitless aggression got the win. Had this happened to me, I would have been pissy for a few minutes, chalked it up as a learning mistake, and quickly got over it. High counter and high accuracy is not the way to go in any fight, IMO.

[Guest]

It works for Jacky

[Scooby]

Irrelevant of whether he points fought or not, it is still a robbery and a poor decision.

 

Landing 39 girly love taps still beats his opponent's 2 low kicks that didn't knockdown, cut or rock him. The ability to stuff 49 takedown attempts should also be worth something in itself given the scoring strength of a single successful takedown.

 

Yeah,seems robbed to me,il be careful with low damage now

[DeadDisney]

It works for Jacky

 

Tell me you didn't push B7, tell me you didn't just go old school

[Guest]

My name is Rad.

[RodrigoMachado]

Horrible decision, but if you like to counter, like me, set the damage slider up to the skies.

 

Counter/Accuracy only handed me many decision losses, and extreme Counter/Damage results in less losses and more KO wins.