I posted them based on ADCC rules in the developers forum, and Mike made a few changes. This is what I posted:
Posted 07 September 2013 - 08:43 PM
I think a points based system makes more sense, is less subjective and more realistic.
Something like ADCC:
• Passing the guard = 3 points
• Knee on stomach = 2 points
• Mount position = 2 points
• Back mount with hooks = 3 points
• Takedown (ends Guard or Half Guard) = 2 points
• Clean Takedown (ends passed the guard) = 4 points
• Sweeps (ends Guard or Half Guard) = 2 points
• Clean Sweep (ends passed the guard) = 4 points
I don't think you should be penalized for pulling guard. Only ADCC does that. IBJJF doesn't nor does any other to my knowledge. But you don't get points for it either.
EDIT: Remember that you have to hold the position for 3 sec, so if he passes directly into mount, he doesn't get 3+2, he just gets the higher score of 3